You run a 20% off weekend. The shop is busy, the sales total is the best of the month, and it feels like a win. Then the month closes and there is less money left over than usual. Nothing went wrong with the sale. The math was always going to do that.
A discount comes out of your profit, not your price. Your costs don’t go on sale when your prices do, so every dollar you take off is a dollar of profit gone. That is why a discount that looks small can remove half of what you earn on each sale.
Why a 20% discount costs more than 20%
Take a product you sell for $40 that costs you $24 to buy or make. You keep $16 on each one, which is a 40% gross margin. (If that term is fuzzy, gross profit vs net profit explains it.)
Now take 20% off. The price drops by $8 to $32. The cost is still $24. Your profit per sale falls from $16 to $8.
You cut the price by a fifth and your profit per sale by half. To earn the same money as before, you now have to sell twice as many.
A worked example: Fern & Pot
Fern & Pot is a small houseplant shop. Its best seller is a potted monstera at $40. The plant, pot and soil cost $24. The shop sells 200 of them in a normal month.
That is $8,000 of revenue and $3,200 of gross profit (200 × $16). The $3,200 is what goes toward rent, wages and the other fixed costs, and those bills stay the same whether there is a sale on or not.
The owner is thinking about a month-long promotion. Here is what each discount level does, and how many plants the shop would need to sell just to earn the same $3,200:
| Discount | Sale price | Profit per plant | Plants needed for $3,200 | Extra sales needed |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| None | $40 | $16 | 200 | – |
| 5% | $38 | $14 | 229 | about 14% |
| 10% | $36 | $12 | 267 | about 33% |
| 15% | $34 | $10 | 320 | 60% |
| 20% | $32 | $8 | 400 | 100% |
| 25% | $30 | $6 | 534 | about 167% |
| 30% | $28 | $4 | 800 | 300% |
Plant counts are rounded up to the next whole plant. Look at the 20% row: 400 plants, double the usual number, only to end up where the shop started. At 30% off it needs four times its normal sales. At 40% off it would be selling at cost, and no amount of volume fixes that.
What if sales rise, but not enough?
Say the 20% sale goes well and sales jump by half, to 300 plants.
- Revenue: 300 × $32 = $9,600, up 20% from $8,000
- Gross profit: 300 × $8 = $2,400, down 25% from $3,200
The shop was busier, handled 100 more plants and made $800 less. This is the trap. Anyone looking only at revenue would say the sale worked.
The quick formula
You don’t need a table every time. One line does it:
Extra sales needed (%) = discount % ÷ (gross margin % − discount %)
For Fern & Pot: 20 ÷ (40 − 20) = 1.00, so 100% more sales. The same 20% discount looks very different at other margins:
- 60% margin: 20 ÷ 40 = 50% more sales
- 40% margin: 20 ÷ 20 = 100% more sales
- 30% margin: 20 ÷ 10 = 200% more sales, which means three times your normal volume
The thinner your margin, the more a discount hurts. If the discount is equal to or bigger than your margin, the formula has no answer, because you make nothing or lose money on every sale.
Two notes. Use the gross margin of the product you are discounting, not the average for the whole business. And the formula assumes your cost per unit stays the same when you sell more.
Costs the formula doesn’t show
- Customers who would have paid full price. Regulars get the discount too. On those sales you gave money away and gained nothing.
- Sales pulled forward. Some buyers were going to buy next month anyway. The sale month looks strong and the month after looks weak.
- Customers who learn to wait. If you run a sale every few weeks, the sale price becomes the price people expect.
- More work for the same money. Double the orders means double the packing, questions and returns.
When a discount does make sense
None of this means you should never discount. It means a discount needs a job to do.
- Clearing stock that is losing value. A plant that will wilt on the shelf, last season’s design, food near its date. The money is already spent, so compare the sale price with what you would get otherwise, not with full price.
- Winning customers who come back. A first-order discount is a marketing cost. Count it as part of your customer acquisition cost and check that repeat purchases pay it back.
- Filling capacity that would sit empty. An unsold appointment slot on a quiet Tuesday earns nothing.
- Getting something in return. A bigger order, payment upfront or a longer commitment can be worth a lower price.
Alternatives that cost you less
Add value instead of cutting price. Fern & Pot could include a bottle of plant food that costs the shop $3 with every monstera at full price. Profit per sale is $13 instead of $8. To hold $3,200 the shop needs 247 plants, about 23% more than usual, instead of 100% more.
Narrow the discount. One product, first-time customers only, a minimum spend, a firm end date. Each limit cuts the number of full-price sales you give away.
Run the math in reverse. If Fern & Pot raised the price 10% to $44, profit per plant would be $20. It could lose 20% of its sales, down to 160 plants, and still earn the same $3,200. If your prices have not moved in a while, read how to price a product before you plan another sale.
If you sell your time
Freelancers and service businesses have an extra problem: hours are limited. A designer who takes 20% off a $1,000 project does the same work for $800, and cannot make it up on volume because there are no extra hours to sell. If a client needs a lower price, cut the scope rather than the rate. Fewer revisions, fewer pages or a longer deadline all cost you less than doing the full job for less money.
What to do before your next sale
- Work out the gross margin on the exact product or service you plan to discount.
- Put the discount through the formula and get the extra sales you need to stand still.
- Check that number against your own past promotions. If your last sale lifted volume by 30%, don’t plan around 100%.
- Write down what the discount is for: clear stock, win new customers, or fill quiet days. If you can’t name the job, skip it.
- Set limits and an end date before you announce it.
- Afterwards, compare gross profit in dollars with a normal period, not revenue.
A discount is a cost like any other, and it deserves the same question you would ask of an ad or a new hire: what do I get back for this? For the other numbers worth checking each month, see our guide to small business finance basics.
